Why Good Strategies Fail: Low Trust

A quote by Adam Grant on a blue background reads: "Great teams have trust at the heart of their success. If you don’t trust each other, you’ll play safe. Trust makes it possible to aim higher, to leap further, and to know someone has your back if you fall." This underscores the importance of leadership.

It’s confounding and disappointing, but often, the problem comes down to employee buy-in. Without it, even the most promising strategies hit a wall of indifference, resistance, or lack of inertia.

Welcome to the Questions for Leaders Series, where we’ll break down some of the most common disconnects and offer ideas for improving buy-in.

Employees With High Trust Contribute To Leadership Success

Trust is key to employee buy-in, and that buy-in is essential to the success of your business. Yet, many leaders fail to recognize the negative impact of a credibility gap. Consider these statistics from the MIT Sloan Management Review:

Your employees with high trust are 260% more motivated to work, have 41% lower absenteeism rates, and are 50% less likely to look for another job.

According to Gallup, only 21% of employees report trusting their organizations’ leadership, and the numbers are trending in the wrong direction.

It’s a bleak thought that 79% of employees don’t trust their leaders, but it’s also a tremendous opportunity.

79 % of employees do not trust their leadership.


Are you accessible to employees at all levels? Do they see you out and about or only in the executive suite? Make an effort to be present, greet people, and show interest in their work.

Do you share information openly? Explain the intent behind decisions and provide context for better understanding, be honest about challenges, and be forthcoming about lessons learned.

Demonstrating a willingness to incorporate feedback and adjust the course builds trust in your fairness and sound judgment. I’m not advocating reversing your strategic direction, but rather suggesting you might gather feedback on impacts before locking in on a direction. Refining your plan slightly based on that feedback might be the key to an exponentially more successful outcome.

Leadership is fundamentally about inspiring people. If your team doesn’t connect with you personally or believe in the path forward, even the most superb strategy may fail.

Next time, we’ll cover another vital question: “Do they understand the plan?” Until then, consider increasing your visibility, transparency, and flexibility factors. You may be surprised by the boost it provides to your strategic initiatives.  

author avatar
tapestryadvisorygroup.com
Skip to content